Buffalo Bills quarterback Josh Allen’s recent win of the 2025 NFL Most Valuable Player (MVP) award has elicited a range of reactions from fans and analysts alike. While many celebrated his achievement, others expressed surprise and skepticism.
A significant point of contention is that Allen was not selected for the All-Pro first team, an honor that went to Baltimore Ravens quarterback Lamar Jackson. This discrepancy is notable, as the same 50 voters determine both the All-Pro selections and the MVP award. Historically, it’s rare for a player to win MVP without being a first-team All-Pro; the last instances were John Elway in 1987 and Steve McNair in 2003.
Statistical comparisons further fueled the debate. Jackson led in several key metrics, including passing yards, touchdowns, and rushing yards. Despite this, Allen secured 27 first-place MVP votes, narrowly surpassing Jackson’s 23, leading to a close victory with a 21-point margin (383 to 362).
On social media, reactions were mixed. Some fans expressed shock and disappointment, believing Jackson’s superior statistics made him the more deserving candidate. Memes and comments highlighted the surprise, with many questioning the decision-making process behind the award.
Conversely, Allen’s supporters celebrated his MVP win, emphasizing his leadership and the Buffalo Bills’ impressive 13-4 record during the season. In his acceptance speech, Allen expressed gratitude to his teammates, coaches, and family, notably acknowledging his fiancée, Hailee Steinfeld, as his “rock.”
The debate underscores the subjective nature of MVP selections, where factors beyond individual statistics, such as team success and leadership qualities, play a crucial role in the voting process.
